Prop 8 Supporters may lose their case against Judge Walker

Good news, of sorts... It looks like Judge Walker's ruling won't be overturned.

A federal appeals court on Thursday expressed reservations about putting a swift end to the legal challenge to California's Proposition 8 because the judge who struck down the state's gay marriage ban was in a long-term, same-sex relationship when he ruled last year.

During a hearing in San Francisco, a three-judge 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel peppered Proposition 8's lawyer with questions suggesting they were troubled by the charge that former Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker was biased because he failed to publicly disclose his relationship. While the judges did likewise pose several tough questions to gay rights lawyers, they appeared reluctant to agree with the argument Walker's ruling should be set aside based on his lengthy relationship with a male physician.

In particular, the judges were skeptical that Walker had an obligation to disclose whether he had a desire to marry his partner before the January 2010 trial.

So, hopefully this silly mess from the haters will be dropped and kicked aside. 

source

Judge Ware Rejects Motion to Vacate Judge Walker’s Ruling

Judge Ware denied the haters' claim that Judge Walker was biased on the Prop 8 case.

He said:

"It is not reasonable to presume that a judge is incapable of making an impartial decision about the constitutionality of a law, solely because, as a citizen, the judge could be affected by the proceedings," U.S. District Judge James Ware wrote in his ruling Tuesday.

Here's the ruling
798

source

NCLR Executive Director Kate Kendell speaks on Yesterday's Prop 8 Case

Judge Ware: Judge Walker's sexuality is Non-Issue in the Prop. 8 case

Judge James Ware

The haters believed that Judge Walker's sexuality and relationship played a huge role in his decision over Prop 8. They forced this issue in for a hearing today, hoping to erase his ruling.

Well, that didn't work out so good for them today. The Judge overseeing his mess said that there was no evidence that Walker's sexuality tripped up the Prop 8 case.

A federal judge questioned Monday whether the judge who presided over the Proposition 8 trial had a duty to disclose his same-sex relationship if he did not intend to marry his long-term partner.


U.S. District Chief Judge James Ware said during a court hearing that there was no evidence that retired Judge Vaughn R. Walker ever wished to marry his partner, a physician.


Sponsors of Proposition 8, the 2008 ballot measure that resurrected a ban on same-sex marriage, argue that Walker’s ruling against the marriage ban should be wiped from the books because his long-term relationship created an interest in the outcome of the case.


Ware, who is African American, said the Proposition 8 case was the first to test the need for a judge’s recusal in a case in which the judge is gay. Ware noted that “the same kind of struggle” has affected female judges and jurists who are racial minorities.


“This is the first case where same-sex relationship is the subject for disqualifying a judge, so it is important that we treat it seriously and get it right,” Ware said.

The haters were stupid to do this. They are so desperate to stop gay marriage, it's getting ridic. Just let it go, we will win.

source 

Court set to hear Prop 8 Supporters concerns over Judge Walker's Ruling

This is ridic, but I guess everyone deserves their day in court. On June 13, a hearing has been scheduled to see if Judge Walker's ruling should be tossed out because the he's is gay and in a relationship.

Chief U.S. District Judge James Ware said Wednesday he was fast-tracking the motion involving his retired predecessor, former Chief Judge Vaughn Walker.

Lawyers for the sponsors of the voter-approved ban asked Ware to vacate Walker's August 2010 decision overturning the ban as a violation of gay Californians' civil rights.


Backers of Proposition 8 said Walker should have recused himself or disclosed his relationship status before trial to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest.

The judge, who left the bench at the end of February, recently revealed that he has been in a relationship with the same man for 10 years, but said he never considered removing himself from the case.

Basically, the haters think Walker was being unfair. Interesting, considering that they are being bigots about all of this. That's unfair.

source

Prop 8 Supporters want to Overturn Judge Walker's ruling because he got a Man

Haters are going to hate. The Prop 8 supporters are trying their best to keep the hateful law alive.

They want to strike down Judge Walker's ruling because he's gay and he's has a MAN!
Here's the scoop:

Lawyers for Protect Marriage, the coalition of religious and conservative groups that sponsored Proposition 8, however, have not previously raised his sexual orientation as a legal issue.

Protect Marriage general counsel Andy Pugno said that changed when the judge this month told a group of courthouse reporters about his 10-year relationship. The issue is not that Walker is gay, but that his relationship status made him too similar to the same-sex couples who sued for the right to marry, Pugno said.

"We deeply regret the necessity of this motion. But if the courts are to require others to follow the law, the courts themselves must do so as well," Pugno added.

Walker said at the time that he did not consider his sexual orientation to be any more a reason for recusal than another judge's race or gender normally would be.

They need to quit this show and stay out of Judge Walker's private business. I'm sure he was fair and true to the case. Their silly attempts to stop the inevitable is tired and desperate.

Let justice be, haters.

source

Judge Walker will leave the bench next year

Bittersweet news, gang. Judge Vaughn Walker, the man who ruled that Prop 8 was unconstitutional, is leaving the bench in February.

In a press release from the United States District Court for the Northern District of California, Walker announced he plans step down as chief judge effective December 31 and that he notified President Barack Obama by letter today that he would leave the court in February.

District Judge James Ware will assume the post of chief judge of the Northern District on January 1. Upon leaving the federal bench, Walker plans to return to the private sector.

In his letter to the president, Walker wrote, "Concluding 21 years of judicial service, I leave the bench with the highest respect and regard for the federal judiciary, its judges and their staff and the essential role they fulfill in our constitutional system."

It will be sad to see him go, but at least he will leave on a high note.

source

Prop 8 Supporters attack Judge Walker's... Judgement?

This fools just won't quit! Haters are now, going after Judge Walker!
These lawyers are begging the federal appeals court to overturn Judge Walker's decision, claiming he was "egregiously selective and one-sided."

Please read the brief:

Prop 8 backers target trial judge